No, not even remotely close. It's been discussed with numbers here before.21forme said:Should a BJ be doubled against a bust card in 6:5?
Go figure yourself. Even money == insurance only in 3:2 games.ArcticInferno said:Anyway, the 6:5 blackjack pay out rule doesn’t affect the insurance side bet.
Insurance (or even money) is only a side bet; nothing more.
Does the dealer’s outfit affect the probability of a ten being in the hole?
Does the cocktail service affect the probability of a ten being in the hole?
The ratio of the tens to non-tens of the remaining deck composition is the only factor that indicates the probability of a ten being in the hole.
The rules, regardless of how awful they are, doesn’t affect the probability of a ten being in the hole.
So, take insurance (or even money) only if the count warrants it.
Remember, you’re not insuring your hand. You're making an independent side bet regarding the probability of a ten being in the hole.
End of discussion.
Simply Wrong on so many counts, no pun intended.ArcticInferno said:It can be mathematically proven that even money and insurance are identical.
Insurance is a side bet regarding the likelihood of a ten being in the hole.
The 6:5 blackjack pay out doesn’t affect/influence/change the likelihood of a ten being in the hole.
What is the probability of a ten being in the hole? Well,... what’s the count?
Why do you ask such question only when an ace is showing?
Why not ask “Is there a ten in the hole?” all the time?
Because that’s the nature of the game, silly.
Anyway, the 6:5 blackjack pay out rule doesn’t affect the insurance side bet.
Insurance (or even money) is only a side bet; nothing more.
Does the dealer’s outfit affect the probability of a ten being in the hole?
Does the cocktail service affect the probability of a ten being in the hole?
The ratio of the tens to non-tens of the remaining deck composition is the only factor that indicates the probability of a ten being in the hole.
The rules, regardless of how awful they are, doesn’t affect the probability of a ten being in the hole.
So, take insurance (or even money) only if the count warrants it.
Remember, you’re not insuring your hand. You're making an independent side bet regarding the probability of a ten being in the hole.
End of discussion.
I think you missed his point. Besides, your statement is wrong anyway. At the end of eight hours your money does NOT rate to be equal. In the 1st instance, you'll be making a -EV bet (even money) only about once every 350 hands or so; in the 2nd instance, you'll be making the same -EV side bet once in every 13 hands. Because of this, the 2nd instance rates to lose significantly more than the 1st.shadroch said:Simply Wrong on so many counts, no pun intended.
If you want to see that insurance and even money are not the same thing, here is a very simple way to do it. Find a video BJ machine that allows both.
Play two hands. On one hand take even money whenever its offered, on the other take insurance whenever it is offered. Play for about eight hours, or long enough to get a few hundred hands that had a dealers Ace. you'll see that your money is equal on both hands, but the hand where you took insurance will have earned more comps, as you put more money at risk.
Insurance is always bad as basic strategy - it is a side not to be confused with the game. It does effects the variance but not the EV.shadroch said:It is much better to insure or take even money in such a game. You forgot the most important part of the equation. The payout does effect your decision.
At 6:5, even money pays 5:1 while insurance still pays 2:1ArcticInferno said:First, the concept of insurance and even money are mathematically identical.
When you play the insurance side bet when the dealer has an ace up, the name of the side bet changes from “insurance” to “even money”. Rose by any other name,...
The insurance is an independent side bet that has nothing to do with your hand. You’re not insuring your hand, but rather, you’re betting that there is or isn’t a ten in the hole, so you need to assess the probability of a ten being in the hole.
The reason for my “mispost” previously was because, as NightStalker said, the mix up between 3:2 vs 6:5 games.
If the insurance payout is 2:1, then you play the insurance side bet when the probability of a ten being in the hole is approximately 50%, which is when the true count is approximately 3 or so. At true count higher than 3, the chance of a ten being in the hole is greater than 50%, so the 2:1 payout is a great side bet.
In a game where the blackjack pays 6:5, if the dealer shows an ace while you have a blackjack, the insurance side bet payout change briefly during that moment. For a brief moment when the dealer shows an ace and you have a blackjack, the insurance pays 5:1 rather than 2:1. If the insurance side bet pays 5:1, then play the side bet when the probability of a ten being in the hole is 20% or greater. At what count is the probability of a ten being in the hole 20% or greater? When the count is negative. So,... basically, take even money at the 6:5 game.
very good questionWABJ11 said:Final answer:
Take even money at 6:5 BJ or not?
Wait, wait. This whole time I've thought this thread was just silly, uh, I mean, theoretical. Even money in 6:5 blackjack... yeah right. But unless I've missed the sarcasm in Sucker's message... are you saying there are casinos that offer even money in 6:5 games?!?Sucker said:Final answer: If a casino that pays 6:5 on blackjack gives you the option to take even money if you have a BJ and the dealer has an ace upcard - TAKE EVEN MONEY. IT'S NOT EVEN A CLOSE PLAY.
Come to our home game, but my night banking I won't be offering even money anymore.Zero said:Wait, wait. This whole time I've thought this thread was just silly, uh, I mean, theoretical. Even money in 6:5 blackjack... yeah right. But unless I've missed the sarcasm in Sucker's message... are you saying there are casinos that offer even money in 6:5 games?!?
0
A 6:5 home game? Words just fail me...WABJ11 said:Come to our home game...
No thanks, I just say no to 6:5 :joker:WABJ11 said:Come to our home game, but my night banking I won't be offering even money anymore.