my first foray into card counting

dzgroundhog

New Member
Tl;dr. I’m at work and bored so I wrote a novel.

I’ve been intrigued by card counting ever since I read Bringing Down the House a few years ago. Last winter, I took a week-long trip to Vegas. Leading up to the trip, I got some really basic counting info and spent a little bit of time practicing counting down decks. I didn’t really know anything about how to increase or decrease bet sizes, but it didn’t matter much because I ended up having high negative counts almost every time I played (which wasn’t very much because I was playing a lot of poker, maybe 15 6-deck shoes for the whole trip).

I’m going again this winter, so I decided I’d really give counting a shot and picked up KO. I spent a good three weeks counting down decks and dealing hands to myself until I was comfortable enough to try to count at my local casino last weekend during my weekly trip to play poker.

The main problem I have is that I really can’t set aside more than $500 right now. I already decided that any fantasy football winnings are going straight into my Vegas gambling bankroll, so I could be adding to it just before my trip. But that still won’t leave me with more than 200 units ($5 units obv.) in essentially a best-case scenario.

Anyways…I get to the casino and head to the blackjack pit and since it’s a Saturday night, there’s nothing but $15 minimum tables and they’re all 8-deck. At least they stand on soft 17 and the rules are pretty good about re-splitting pairs and doubling down. So I figure I have no choice but to wong in to a table when the count gets good enough to bet at least 3 units.

I finally find a dealer who’s shuffling and start counting and the count gets fairly high real quick. And of course since it’s getting high, the table is getting destroyed by the dealer so plenty of seats are open. I wong in after about 3 decks played with a RC of -2 so I put out a $20 bet and get a stiff hand vs. a 4 and end up losing. At least the count stayed at -2 and I get dealt a 20 and win to get even while everybody else was dealt babies, driving the count up to +6. $50 bet so I’m a little nervous (which is the most I’ve ever bet at a table game because I’m a low-roller, yet winning or losing a $500 pot in poker doesn’t phase me) and I get an 11 vs. a 5. I DD and draw some paint and the dealer has whatever and I’m up $100 and the count is still high enough to warrant a $50 bet. I get a stiff hand and bust while other people get blackjacks and the dealer gets a 20. This goes on for three more hands until the count goes sour and I’m down $30. That got ugly quick, especially when I’m used to betting $5/hand and getting drunk instead of paying close attention and betting relatively big.

I find another table where the dealer is shuffling and the same thing happens. The count gets good real quick and I wong in and lose three hands real fast and I’m out $100. At this point, I decided to just go play some poker and maybe I’d give counting another shot if I did alright at the poker table.

While I was playing poker, I started wondering if I had been making mistakes when I was counting since I only counted two tables and they both went positive less than halfway through the shoe. Three hours later I got even on the night, so I headed back to the blackjack pit hoping to back-count some shoes that stayed negative all the way to the cut card to prove to myself that I hadn’t screwed up.

I got my wish and it took three shuffles before I found a good count. Wonged in and nailed a blackjack on my first hand, then pretty much alternated wins and losses for about six hands while the count slowly rose. I was down $30 when the count made a huge jump on one hand and it got up to +9. I stick my $50 bet out there and watch the entire table get dealt 20’s while one guy gets a couple aces. The dealer also has a face card and…yep, and ace underneath. That pushed the count all the way down to a 2 unit bet which I couldn’t make at a $15 minimum table, so I wonged out and headed home since I wasn’t feeling that great and I lost almost 40% of my card-counting.bankroll in about 15 hands.

At least I found out that I’m able to count while still maintaining some sort of conversation; I bumped into a co-worker while I was back-counting a table and was able to talk to him without losing the count. So that made me happy. All that second-hand smoke made me unhappy and gave me a headache. And I thought I the variance wouldn’t bother me much since I played a lot of limit hold’em in the past few months and that game is super swingy, but this is unreal. I’m a little hesitant to try it again at my local joint because I’d hate to drop $500 on stupid 8-deck games when I can use it on double-deck games in Vegas in 2½ months.

Any comments or tips or anything?


DZ
 
Last edited:

21forme

Well-Known Member
Definitely get more practice. The more, the better.

Perhaps easier said than done, but find lower limit tables.

Review the section in the KO book on ROR - very important on what you should bet for your bankroll size.
 

sagefr0g

Well-Known Member
dzgroundhog said:
Tl......... I didn’t really know anything about how to increase or decrease bet sizes, but it didn’t matter much because I ended up having high negative counts ................................................
Any comments or tips or anything?


DZ
proper betting according to the count and according to your risk tolerance and bankroll limitations is key to success.
so you need to learn about ROR risk of ruin and about proper proportional betting according to the advantage you are playing at. get a handle on ideas such as variance, negative and positive fluctuation standard deviation and what that means as to what you can expect result wise as you play over time.
 

dzgroundhog

New Member
sagefr0g said:
proper betting according to the count and according to your risk tolerance and bankroll limitations is key to success.
so you need to learn about ROR risk of ruin and about proper proportional betting according to the advantage you are playing at. get a handle on ideas such as variance, negative and positive fluctuation standard deviation and what that means as to what you can expect result wise as you play over time.
I understand ROR and how to ramp my bets now that I've read KO; I didn't know what I was doing last winter. I also understand variance and how thin my edge is...

How about I just sum it up like this...Does anybody have any tips or advice for someone playing on a short (100 units) bankroll? All I can think of is to do a ton of wonging in very favorable counts and hope for the best.
 

AnIrishmannot2brite

Well-Known Member
dzgroundhog said:
Tl;dr. I’m at work and bored so I wrote a novel.

I’ve been intrigued by card counting ever since I read Bringing Down the House a few years ago. Last winter, I took a week-long trip to Vegas. Leading up to the trip, I got some really basic counting info and spent a little bit of time practicing counting down decks. I didn’t really know anything about how to increase or decrease bet sizes, but it didn’t matter much because I ended up having high negative counts almost every time I played (which wasn’t very much because I was playing a lot of poker, maybe 15 6-deck shoes for the whole trip).

I’m going again this winter, so I decided I’d really give counting a shot and picked up KO. I spent a good three weeks counting down decks and dealing hands to myself until I was comfortable enough to try to count at my local casino last weekend during my weekly trip to play poker.

The main problem I have is that I really can’t set aside more than $500 right now. I already decided that any fantasy football winnings are going straight into my Vegas gambling bankroll, so I could be adding to it just before my trip. But that still won’t leave me with more than 200 units ($5 units obv.) in essentially a best-case scenario.

Anyways…I get to the casino and head to the blackjack pit and since it’s a Saturday night, there’s nothing but $15 minimum tables and they’re all 8-deck. At least they stand on soft 17 and the rules are pretty good about re-splitting pairs and doubling down. So I figure I have no choice but to wong in to a table when the count gets good enough to bet at least 3 units.

I finally find a dealer who’s shuffling and start counting and the count gets fairly high real quick. And of course since it’s getting high, the table is getting destroyed by the dealer so plenty of seats are open. I wong in after about 3 decks played with a RC of -2 so I put out a $20 bet and get a stiff hand vs. a 4 and end up losing. At least the count stayed at -2 and I get dealt a 20 and win to get even while everybody else was dealt babies, driving the count up to +6. $50 bet so I’m a little nervous (which is the most I’ve ever bet at a table game because I’m a low-roller, yet winning or losing a $500 pot in poker doesn’t phase me) and I get an 11 vs. a 5. I DD and draw some paint and the dealer has whatever and I’m up $100 and the count is still high enough to warrant a $50 bet. I get a stiff hand and bust while other people get blackjacks and the dealer gets a 20. This goes on for three more hands until the count goes sour and I’m down $30. That got ugly quick, especially when I’m used to betting $5/hand and getting drunk instead of paying close attention and betting relatively big.

I find another table where the dealer is shuffling and the same thing happens. The count gets good real quick and I wong in and lose three hands real fast and I’m out $100. At this point, I decided to just go play some poker and maybe I’d give counting another shot if I did alright at the poker table.

While I was playing poker, I started wondering if I had been making mistakes when I was counting since I only counted two tables and they both went positive less than halfway through the shoe. Three hours later I got even on the night, so I headed back to the blackjack pit hoping to back-count some shoes that stayed negative all the way to the cut card to prove to myself that I hadn’t screwed up.

I got my wish and it took three shuffles before I found a good count. Wonged in and nailed a blackjack on my first hand, then pretty much alternated wins and losses for about six hands while the count slowly rose. I was down $30 when the count made a huge jump on one hand and it got up to +9. I stick my $50 bet out there and watch the entire table get dealt 20’s while one guy gets a couple aces. The dealer also has a face card and…yep, and ace underneath. That pushed the count all the way down to a 2 unit bet which I couldn’t make at a $15 minimum table, so I wonged out and headed home since I wasn’t feeling that great and I lost almost 40% of my card-counting.bankroll in about 15 hands.

At least I found out that I’m able to count while still maintaining some sort of conversation; I bumped into a co-worker while I was back-counting a table and was able to talk to him without losing the count. So that made me happy. All that second-hand smoke made me unhappy and gave me a headache. And I thought I the variance wouldn’t bother me much since I played a lot of limit hold’em in the past few months and that game is super swingy, but this is unreal. I’m a little hesitant to try it again at my local joint because I’d hate to drop $500 on stupid 8-deck games when I can use it on double-deck games in Vegas in 2½ months.

Any comments or tips or anything?


DZ
You're smarter than me.

Two and one half years ago I started card counting, but i didn't read any books. All I remembered was that Sixty Minutes interview with Ken Uston in 1980 or so where he assigned values to cards.

That was all i knew about blackjack. No basic strategy nothing.

Fortunately i wasn't burned much but man i was staying on all stiff hands regardless of the count. Sheesh! Plus I didn't know that progressive gambling was bunk. A few times in positive counts I learned to triple bets but was probably going overboard at least a little. And I learned through table experience that doubling and splits were a way to make money.

No one ever told me that stuff.

Now i still didn't lose money but didn't make any either. Scares me to think about what might of happened. Plus i had a dandy bankroll back then too. Prior to my kids going to school that is. Had i known what i was doing then i might even have been about to become a full time player by now. If I'd only just bought and read a book on the subject!

Experience s what you get when you don't read the fine print...

Anyway it sounds to me like dzgroundhog is on the right track. He'll make it. So will i. It's scary. Hell it's STILL scary. Later on though YOU feel in control. Even after the occasional losing session. A serenity takes over and you realize it's only some minor negative variance and which will come and go.

There was the time I dumped a HUGE win in online bonuses and still didn't ball my eyes out. A calm prevailed afterwards.
 

EasyRhino

Well-Known Member
Going into a casino iwth $500 in your pocket and making $50 max bets isn't ureasonable, as long as you're okay with a very significant chance of losing that particular $500. If that's your TOTAL bankroll, then you'd want a smaller max bet (and, you know... a day job).

In general I'd look for lower-roller places. Tough in places like AC, but if you're in Vegas, you can go off strip and find $5, $3, and even, sweet jesus, $1 tables. So then something like a $25 max bet can still make some money. (not a LOT of money at those levels, but at least a reasonable profit from a percentage standpoint).

... and I'm not any good at poker, but I understand blackjack has way more variance.
 

dzgroundhog

New Member
EasyRhino said:
Going into a casino iwth $500 in your pocket and making $50 max bets isn't ureasonable, as long as you're okay with a very significant chance of losing that particular $500. If that's your TOTAL bankroll, then you'd want a smaller max bet (and, you know... a day job).

In general I'd look for lower-roller places. Tough in places like AC, but if you're in Vegas, you can go off strip and find $5, $3, and even, sweet jesus, $1 tables. So then something like a $25 max bet can still make some money. (not a LOT of money at those levels, but at least a reasonable profit from a percentage standpoint).

... and I'm not any good at poker, but I understand blackjack has way more variance.
$500 is my total bankroll to start mainly because I don't want to risk any more on the chance that I actually suck at counting and make tons of mistakes. I have a day job that pays the bills and gives me a little spending money; poker is where I get money to buy grown-up toys (like trips to Vegas). If I feel like I'm playing well in the blackjack pits but I drop the first $500, I can always put in a bunch of extra hours at the poker table and use the winnings to rebuild my blackjack bankroll.

I wish there were lower-roller places around here, but this is the only place within an hour's drive that doesn't use CSM's. I really just want to get some practice so I can go balls-out in a few months at $5 double-deck games in Vegas.

I guess I'll just be spending a lot of time back-counting and pretending to look for my friends. At least I know that I can find about 15 tables within 200 feet of each other on a weekend night.
 
Top