Not sure if I "outted" myself in Vegas...

KO-Rob

Member
Background: I'm a math-head. I learned to count for the entertainment and for the challenge. I'm not trying to make a living at it. I learned the KO system, and I'd say I've got it down cold. I go to Vegas once a year for a long weekend; stay on the strip and play maybe 12-18 hours a day (6 deck) while I'm there. I don't jump around tables or casinos. I'll take root at a $10/15 table (lowest min available), spread 10-90, and have at it. My cover is not great...in my experience, I don't really need one at those levels. I'll drink a fair amount, tip a fair amount...try to chat between hands to make up for the fact that I'm quiet during them. No one from dealers to pit bosses have ever seemed to notice or care. I just want to stay for free, enjoy myself, and rack up some comp dollars. That said, it's not like I've ever made a killing. I might fluctuate 800 down here, 600 up there. But after a nice night's work recently, I had a weird experience. I'm wondering if anyone can confirm whether a casino could be behind something like this.

On day 3 of 4 in my trip, I had a couple of great shoes. The count zoomed up, and I'm betting 90 as the dealer busted time after time. I'd say I took 800 out of that one shoe. A friend wandered up to the table just as things got good...I told him to sit down, and he won $350 in minutes. Later, in another nice shoe, I split and doubled to have 6 $75 hands out there, and the dealer busted...I couldn't help but let out a holler on the bust card. I'd say I ended up $1500 for the session. I was very pleased with myself and called it a night after only 8 hours.

The next day, still feeling good, I sat down after lunch expecting to play through to the following AM. Two or three shoes in, nothing has happened. I haven't raised my bet...I did sit out a few hands when the count was hideous. There are only 3 people at the table. I'm in the middle. The count was horrible at one particular moment, when this obnoxious guy comes up...says he wants to play two hands. He looks like 3rd rate mobster from the Sopranos. Mid 50's, gray hair combed back, thick glasses, shiny track suit...moderately out of place in the 20-30something oriented casino I'm in. There are not two empty spots next to each other available. He didn't ask nicely as just about anyone would. Just kinda blustered up and expected me to move over. He gave the dealer a player's card and cashed in for maybe 500. I didn't know if he was in for the long haul, or just to finish out the shoe or something, so I asked him how long he was going to stay...to help me decide whether to shift seats. He said flippantly, "I don't know...15-20 minutes? Probably longer than you." I replied, "You don't know me very well." So I slid my chips over one spot, but kept my seat.

That was moderately odd...next it got weirder. He immediately gets in my ear. He only spoke to me...he ignored the other two people at the table. Asked me where I was from. Then, at the top of the next new shoe, he said quietly, "OK, I'm going to start with one hand, but then I might go to two. Follow my lead." Essentially identifying himself to me as a counter, if I happen to be someone who would recognize it. I would like to ignore him, but he stays in my ear with counting-related comments.

In all my travels before now, I've only stumbled upon one other counter at the low limit tables I play. (And those of you that do it know how obvious it is when the count gets good.) Clearly this guy thinks he's a counter, but he jumped in with two hands at a hideous count, and now he's IDed himself to me intentionally in 2 minutes. Flat out weird. He's obnoxious, and I just want him to go away. In so many words, I tell the guy that I know what he's trying to tell me, but I'm fine, thanks...and that we should not be talking about the things we are talking about. He's like, "I could tell about you...I knew about you. I'd like to talk to you outside of here." Half way through the shoe, again the count was not good. He quietly tells me so, and I quietly agree with him. He then says abruptly, "I guess I'm not staying as long as I thought." And he's gone. He was probably there 5-10 minutes total.

At first, I was just happy he was gone. The other players and even the dealer were making fun of him...the way he blustered in and carried himself. But a minute later, a wave of semi-panic washed over me. I never see other counters. I'm usually very cautious about identifying myself...I won't even tell people I'm a computer programmer. But this clown comes up, and I essentially confessed in 5 minutes that I was counting. And as soon as I did so, he left.

Instead of playing my usual marathon session, I almost immediately bailed, went back to my room, and watched TV the rest of the day/night. I needed to gather my thoughts. I was half expecting a knock at the door. But I've never even bet $100 on a hand...they couldn't possibly care, right? But there's no way this was a coincidence. I hadn't raised my bet at all that day...how could this guy say he "could tell about me?" I flip-flopped like this in my head all night.

I was set to leave at noon the next day, so I figured I had to try to play, just to see if they would deal to me. I didn't want to return next year and get flagged as soon as I sat down. I waited until after check out to make sure I got my comps (not sure if they comp you after they refuse to deal to you). I put in my player's card played a half hour at a $25 table. The count got good, but the cards weren't friendly...I gave back $500 in those 30 minutes. Thankfully nothing happened. But I wish I would have gotten on a hot streak just to confirm that things were all clear.

So...after all that typing...my question to you is, have you ever heard of a casino trying to confirm whether someone is counting like that? I guess if they wanted to put me in the book, that would be the difference between labeling me a suspected counter vs a confirmed counter. But if they noticed me the day before, wouldn't the pit boss or someone else say something? On the flip side, maybe they thought I was part of a team or something, since a friend of mine got up from another table, came over when the count was good, won, and left. And at least I confirmed for them that I am a complete idiot (for identifying myself) and not any sort of threat. Or maybe I really did randomly meet an obnoxious, card-counting knucklehead.

Any thoughts from someone with more experience than me would be appreciated...
 

EasyRhino

Well-Known Member
Wow, that sounds absolutely hilarious. I'd be biting my tongue to keep from asking the guy where I could get a similar mafioso gig with Central Casting... a TRACK SUIT!? That's soo awesome!

I think you're basically fine.

Someone who knows better can correct me on this, but casino employees aren't allowed to play at the table (no shills). A Gaming Control agent theoretically could, but a) counting is legal, and b) seriously? for a $50 bet?

Could you tell if the guy was observing the table at all before "wonging" in? Could you tell if he was with anyone else?

The guy sounds like a harmless doof. He might have been trying to get a date with you or something.

(... then again, if it was like 10AM and he was drunk, it sounds like he might have been doing a bad Ken Uston impersonation, was he wearing polyester?)
 
Last edited:

KO-Rob

Member
Thanks for the insight. If casino employees are not allowed to play, that would definitely be a big vote for "random knucklehead". If anyone can confirm that, I'd appreciate it.

I can't say for sure that he wasn't back-counting, but I kinda doubt it. It was lunchtime on a Monday...definitely not crowded. I don't think anyone was standing around directly behind the table. And he jumped in with two hands late in a shoe with a horrible count. I guess he could have seen that it was the end of a shoe, and played two spots for a few hands just to carve out room at the table to give himself the option moving forward. He didn't appear drunk. At least that would have been entertaining.
 

Sonny

Well-Known Member
I wouldn’t worry about it. I doubt that a casino would pull such a trick just to ID you. If they knew you were counting then the pit boss would have said something or given you some heat. If they wanted to find out if you were counting then they could rewind the tapes and run a skills check to confirm it. I would have to agree with your “random knucklehead” theory. If a real AP noticed your skill and wanted to talk to you, he wouldn’t do it at the tables. He might have been trying to make you uncomfortable so that you’d leave (similar to clearing out ploppies) or maybe he’s just a weirdo.

You were right to cash in your comps first, but don’t worry about getting a knock on the door. If they had confirmed you as a counter they would just 86 you the next time you showed up. They’re not going to do any more work than they have to, unless you’re a high-stakes player.

-Sonny-
 

shadroch

Well-Known Member
Some one want to comment on Rhinos no shills statement? Is he correct that a casino employee can't play(no shills)? I thought the rule was they could play but had to idenitify themselves if asked?
 

GeorgeD

Well-Known Member
shadroch said:
Some one want to comment on Rhinos no shills statement? Is he correct that a casino employee can't play(no shills)? I thought the rule was they could play but had to idenitify themselves if asked?
Woman working at the deli counter at the local indian joint told me she wasn't allowed to play at any of their 3 area casinos. She could go to others, though. Don't know if this applies elsewhere.
 
He may have recognized you as a counter (you never know who is watching you play over your shoulder) and didn't want to cheat you out of any EV by spreading to 2 hands while you are playing 1 hand. I feel self-conscious about that myself; it's just like Wonging in on another counter. But if you both spread to 2 at the same time, there's no problem.
 

Mimosine

Well-Known Member
KO-Rob said:
Any thoughts from someone with more experience than me would be appreciated...
wow. weird. i'd be paranoid too, but take the other peoples' advice on here and take a deep breath.

i was playing with a bunch of college kids one night and i started talking with them about what they studied and inadvertently revealed what i do for a living (high-end science related), at which time the dealer (who was shuffling) gave me a suspiscious glance. i barely play with an advantage right now, so i'm not worried about heat, but in that moment - at least at the table i need to think of something boring for an occupation that won't arrouse any suspicion or warrant further conversation which might distract my play.... HA!

carpenter maybe? jiffy lube employee? no --- unemployed!
 

Kasi

Well-Known Member
I think if a casino knows you are counting, whether you are winning or losing, betting big or small, you're outta there!

But next time save your confessions for the confessional - some tables I gather even have microphones!
 

KO-Rob

Member
I always kinda figured that a casino would *love* somebody who thinks they can count, but isn't very good at it. You could even count perfectly, but still give them the advantage if you're too timid with your bet spread. So I imagined that if they suspect you're a counter, they could watch you for a while and analyze your play before they make a scene and refuse to deal to you. (I have no facts to back this up...maybe I read it somewhere once and it just made sense to me.)

But you are absolutely right, Kasi. At the very least, I have learned a valuable lesson. Play dumb at all times.

A follow-up question...let's say a casino identifies you as a small-time counter. They have your name & info from your comp card. Do you automatically go in the big book, or in some database they have, or might it just be that a pit boss or someone in the control room might take note of you for the next few days and later forget about you?

I've often wondered whether it's wise to have a comp card. Do most of you use one? On one hand, the free rooms and meals are nice...like guaranteed profits. But on the other hand, you're giving up your anonymity. Wouldn't it call attention to me if I'm playing 12+ hours a day, averaging $25-50 a hand, *without* submitting a card?
 

ihate17

Well-Known Member
Casinos are all different

KO-Rob said:
I always kinda figured that a casino would *love* somebody who thinks they can count, but isn't very good at it. You could even count perfectly, but still give them the advantage if you're too timid with your bet spread. So I imagined that if they suspect you're a counter, they could watch you for a while and analyze your play before they make a scene and refuse to deal to you. (I have no facts to back this up...maybe I read it somewhere once and it just made sense to me.)

But you are absolutely right, Kasi. At the very least, I have learned a valuable lesson. Play dumb at all times.

A follow-up question...let's say a casino identifies you as a small-time counter. They have your name & info from your comp card. Do you automatically go in the big book, or in some database they have, or might it just be that a pit boss or someone in the control room might take note of you for the next few days and later forget about you?

I've often wondered whether it's wise to have a comp card. Do most of you use one? On one hand, the free rooms and meals are nice...like guaranteed profits. But on the other hand, you're giving up your anonymity. Wouldn't it call attention to me if I'm playing 12+ hours a day, averaging $25-50 a hand, *without* submitting a card?
I have to disagree with Kasi about if a casino knows that you count, you are gone. Now if you flaunt it or do something to embarass them, even if you are a red chip player, you are definately gone.
There are many casinos that will let a red chip counter play. Most likely this is because no one is evaluating any red chip players.
There are many casinos smart enough to evaluate a counter and know if he has a winning game or not and based on this, may let him play.
There are many casinos that will look at your blackjack play and also look at what else you and if you have a significant other, play. If your blackjack game nets you $30 per hour of play, but between you and the wife, you will lose $60 per hour on the slots and the hours work out, you can always play in a smart casino.

Dumb casinos and sweat shops (mostly dumb) will back you off without evaluating your ability (they might not be capable of proper evaluation) or looking at other games. My experiences in the past would certainly put Harrah's and Coast into the category of dumb casinos, as I know several counters backed off in both places who had weak games and also lost much more at VP than they ever made (actually I think they also lost here) at blackjack.

So, you need to know a little about the casino. Spread $10-$90, at places like Harrah's, El Cortez or SunCoast and you might be backed off. The same spread at MGM or Mandalay Bay and I doubt anyone even knows you are playing.

ihate17
 

EasyRhino

Well-Known Member
ihate17 said:
Spread $10-$90, at places like Harrah's, El Cortez or SunCoast and you might be backed off.
I was just doing that at El Cortez! And even though I only played for an hour, I felt as excited as a kid that had just robbed a candy store. Second-funnest part of my Vegas trip.

I'll definitely vouch for IH17's argument from my limited personal experience. All my adverse action so far has been at places where even a $50 bet is kind of noteworthy. There are a lot of places where red-chippers just don't exist, counters or not. If you were on the strip, unless you were at Slots-o-Fun or something, I would guess you would fall in the "not-existing" category (IH17, is Harrah's really that bad? I only walked through).
 

KO-Rob

Member
I agree that the spread you can get away with depends on the casino. Where I was, the table minimums usually range from 10-50 (although you can get 5 if you're willing to accept 6:5 or continuous shuffle...as if). At the 10-15 tables the dealers used to give a "check play" call whenever someone bet 100+ (although I didn't notice that on this trip). That's why I kept my max bet below 100...I didn't want any attention. I'd say I've always felt I was safely in the non-existent category, but I also hadn't taken $1500 out of a $10 table until this instance. That can't be too common. And since that was immediately followed by this weird encounter with a counter directly approaching me...that's what prompted me to seek the advice of others.
 
Top