Another funny story, need legal advice

ScottH

Well-Known Member
This is relating to me recent post about the dealer's who don't take too well to my playing style (no tipping).
http://www.blackjackinfo.com/bb/showthread.php?t=6247

After that incident, I heard through my connections that they were on to my game and they were thinking that it was illegal for me to count cards there. Of course I was not scared of them, and went right back.

Me and supercoolmancool had decided that straight counting that game wasn't worth our time so we planned to do team tactics and hit them even harder. Anyway, we both sat down at the empty table, and we saw the same dealer as always reading a book. She tried to ignore us but we just sat there and didn't leave. Finally she says to us, "I don't think I can deal to you two." We asked why is that and she says, "We got a call from downtown saying you were counting cards."

Trying to convince her that we weren't was not going to be worth it, it wouldn't have worked. So we instead started questioning the legality of her refusing to deal to us. We live in ND, and I do not think there is a law that allows for casinos to bar cardcounters.

She looked for about 10 minutes and found some statement that said something like, "Any player using a fraudulent scheme no matter what the amount is subject to a 5000 dollar fine and/or 5 years in jail. We explained that cardcounting is not illegal so that does not apply to us.

She then said that the house rules state she has the right to refuse service to anyone. I mentioned that rules and laws are two different things. She said she had the State Law right there. I asked her if she could show me the law that allows her to refuse dealing to me because I was counting cards. She was looking quite annoyed at that point. She said, "It will take me 2 hours to find it, are you just going to sit there while I look?" I then said, "Keep looking, but we'll be back."

So to the legal aspect of this. Is there any legal action we can take on this? The situation is we are in ND, and this is a blackjack table in a bar. Does anyone know the law for ND enough to help us and determine if there is anything here to pursue? Also, are there lawyers that will take a case and you only pay if you win? This is not worth pursuing for me unless it is at no cost to me. It probably still isn't, but I think it would be funny, and I would like to make a point.

I don't know if this makes a difference or not, but this is a casino that donates the winnings to charity.
 

EasyRhino

Well-Known Member
You kids and your crazy hijinks.

There's probably not a lot of specific gaming law in North Dakota, although it would be worth looking at. As a hunch, I think you'd need to research on the enforceability of the "right to refuse service to anyone" clause in North Dakota. And no, you won't be able to claim a civil rights violation because you're young and nerdy.

For general edification purposes, I would recommend finding and reading a) the North Dakota statutes involving gambling, and b) all of the regulations put out by the North Dakota gaming commission (or whatever the rulemaking body is).

... also, if this casino donates all or most of its winnings to charity, and you guys are eating into those winnings, that really does mean that you're taking food from the mouths of orphans! Sweet!
 

ScottH

Well-Known Member
EasyRhino said:
As a hunch, I think you'd need to research on the enforceability of the "right to refuse service to anyone" clause in North Dakota.
Do even public places really have the right to refuse service to anyone without good reason? I know private casinos can ban you even if there reason is "because you had a yellow shirt on", but can a place like a bar do that?

EasyRhino said:
... also, if this casino donates all or most of its winnings to charity, and you guys are eating into those winnings, that really does mean that you're taking food from the mouths of orphans! Sweet!
Trust me, these charities are doing just fine. Can you imagine the level of play and discipline you would see at blackjack in a bar? I have played at a whole bunch and I don't even think I've ever seen anyone actually walk away ahead money.

Just the other day there was a girl who was losing 100 after 100. They just kept coming out. Then she started writing checks. She was clearly depressed about the amount she was losing and had an obvious addiction. Nobody could get her to stop. So for them to let her keep playing and to boot me with my miniscule EV of 10-15 dollars per hour... I can't feel that bad about taking some of that money back, even it it is from charity...
 
ScottH said:
This is relating to me recent post about the dealer's who don't take too well to my playing style (no tipping).
http://www.blackjackinfo.com/bb/showthread.php?t=6247

After that incident, I heard through my connections that they were on to my game and they were thinking that it was illegal for me to count cards there. Of course I was not scared of them, and went right back.

Me and supercoolmancool had decided that straight counting that game wasn't worth our time so we planned to do team tactics and hit them even harder. Anyway, we both sat down at the empty table, and we saw the same dealer as always reading a book. She tried to ignore us but we just sat there and didn't leave. Finally she says to us, "I don't think I can deal to you two." We asked why is that and she says, "We got a call from downtown saying you were counting cards."

Trying to convince her that we weren't was not going to be worth it, it wouldn't have worked. So we instead started questioning the legality of her refusing to deal to us. We live in ND, and I do not think there is a law that allows for casinos to bar cardcounters.

She looked for about 10 minutes and found some statement that said something like, "Any player using a fraudulent scheme no matter what the amount is subject to a 5000 dollar fine and/or 5 years in jail. We explained that cardcounting is not illegal so that does not apply to us.

She then said that the house rules state she has the right to refuse service to anyone. I mentioned that rules and laws are two different things. She said she had the State Law right there. I asked her if she could show me the law that allows her to refuse dealing to me because I was counting cards. She was looking quite annoyed at that point. She said, "It will take me 2 hours to find it, are you just going to sit there while I look?" I then said, "Keep looking, but we'll be back."

So to the legal aspect of this. Is there any legal action we can take on this? The situation is we are in ND, and this is a blackjack table in a bar. Does anyone know the law for ND enough to help us and determine if there is anything here to pursue? Also, are there lawyers that will take a case and you only pay if you win? This is not worth pursuing for me unless it is at no cost to me. It probably still isn't, but I think it would be funny, and I would like to make a point.

I don't know if this makes a difference or not, but this is a casino that donates the winnings to charity.
Don't be crazy, kid. You're dealing with a disreputable business in an area of low law enforcement and you are asking for trouble if you even set foot in their building again. They can call in sheriff's deputies who will arrest you, put you in a cell for 48 hours with homosexuals and violent criminals and at the end say, "Yeah, I guess you were right, card counting isn't illegal. Have a nice day."

Once a casino recognizes you and decides not to deal to you, you're done. Go play someplace else. You and your partner live in a part of the country with some very beatable games for players at your level- why even screw around with a casino where they already know you? Get out there and try something different.
 

supercoolmancool

Well-Known Member
Automatic Monkey said:
Don't be crazy, kid. You're dealing with a disreputable business in an area of low law enforcement and you are asking for trouble if you even set foot in their building again. They can call in sheriff's deputies who will arrest you, put you in a cell for 48 hours with homosexuals and violent criminals and at the end say, "Yeah, I guess you were right, card counting isn't illegal. Have a nice day."

Once a casino recognizes you and decides not to deal to you, you're done. Go play someplace else. You and your partner live in a part of the country with some very beatable games for players at your level- why even screw around with a casino where they already know you? Get out there and try something different.
I thought false arrest was an advantage play.
 
supercoolmancool said:
I thought false arrest was an advantage play.
Usually not. For every false arrestee you hear about who wins a lawsuit, there are 100 more who get bitched buggered and bewildered, and sent home empty-handed. Leave the courthouse heroics for someone else who is backed into a corner, and dream of Minnesota.
 

ScottH

Well-Known Member
Automatic Monkey said:
Don't be crazy, kid. You're dealing with a disreputable business in an area of low law enforcement and you are asking for trouble if you even set foot in their building again. They can call in sheriff's deputies who will arrest you, put you in a cell for 48 hours with homosexuals and violent criminals and at the end say, "Yeah, I guess you were right, card counting isn't illegal. Have a nice day."

Once a casino recognizes you and decides not to deal to you, you're done. Go play someplace else. You and your partner live in a part of the country with some very beatable games for players at your level- why even screw around with a casino where they already know you? Get out there and try something different.
These are not indian casinos that can try some crazy BS on us because they have their own laws. Also, I don't think the jails around here are all that dangerous at all. I mean, it's only ND...

I know it's probably a waste of time, but I really think it would be fun to sue a charity. If it wouldn't cost me anything and wasn't a hassle, I would proceed with it. I just think it will be a big time-wasting hassle.
 

biggamejames

Well-Known Member
What kind of casino allows the dealers to read books while attending a table?

Why would you even begin to debate the legality of your play with a dealer?

Arent you supposed to talk to a pit boss not some dodo head dealer reading a book?

why would you even walk into a casino where the dealer reads a book at the table????:confused:
 

eps6724

Well-Known Member
ScottH said:
I know it's probably a waste of time, but I really think it would be fun to sue a charity. If it wouldn't cost me anything and wasn't a hassle, I would proceed with it. I just think it will be a big time-wasting hassle.
I think that you'll be hard pressed to find anyone willing to even think of taking a case like this for this very reason. Charity work, reguardless of how much (or little) actually makes it to the Charity, still remain very much sacred cows. Anyone taking a case like this walks a very thin line of loosing any credibility for their future.

Not to mention that a lawsuit is for one of two things-someone to make money for themselves, or someone to make a name for themselves. In either case, that someone will NOT be you. Why not, instead, offer to 'help their charity' by donating your time dealing for them? Might also give you a different take on the game, find a couple of new ways to exploit it, and show them that you're bigger than them? (Kinda like 'Hey, you're jerks, but we want to help your cause').

Or, if you REALLY want to 'step above the fray', you're in ND, right? Go tilt at windmills, or wind fans, or whatever you call those goofy things up there. And you can take turns-who wants to be Sancho, who wants to be Don Quixote?:eek:
 

nc-tom

Well-Known Member
Why Bother

Hey Scott why bother with all the leagel bs. i thought you and SCM were going to move to LV and make big money playing bj. Why take a chance at mucking up your future play?
 

NDN21

Well-Known Member
Another

You guys have been busted and it's too late for this casino unless you can jump in your time machine and go back and not get busted.

Why don't you try working on your camo techniques, not for this casino but for the next one?

Just how obvious were you guys?
 

zengrifter

Banned
NDN21 said:
You guys have been busted and it's too late for this casino ...Why don't you try working on your camo techniques, not for this casino but for the next one?
Disagree - the real challenge is camo for THIS casino! zg
 

Sonny

Well-Known Member
ScottH said:
Do even public places really have the right to refuse service to anyone without good reason? I know private casinos can ban you even if there reason is "because you had a yellow shirt on", but can a place like a bar do that?
Yes, it is within their innkeeper’s rights. As long as they are not discriminating against a protected class (gender, race, religion, etc.) then they can tell you to leave whenever they want.

As others have pointed out, you guys have been made. Even if you force the dealer to deal to you, they can easily take countermeasures to make the game worthless. They can deal so slow that you are wasting your time, they can shuffle after every hand, they can make numerous payout “mistakes” against you, and generally make you feel unwelcome. This place is no longer in a +EV situation. Learn from your mistakes and move on.

-Sonny-
 

ScottH

Well-Known Member
biggamejames said:
What kind of casino allows the dealers to read books while attending a table?

Why would you even begin to debate the legality of your play with a dealer?

Arent you supposed to talk to a pit boss not some dodo head dealer reading a book?

why would you even walk into a casino where the dealer reads a book at the table????:confused:
There is no such thing as a pit boss in these "casinos". It's just the dealers, with no pit watching.

She was reading a book since nobody was at the tables at the time.
 

ScottH

Well-Known Member
zengrifter said:
Disagree - the real challenge is camo for THIS casino! zg
I don't really want to play any camo at these games. They aren't very good. They are 4d, das, s17, 70-75% pen. The big thing is, the limits are low, 1-25. You can't really make much unless you spread huge. So that's what I do, I spread from 1-2x25. They only allow you to go to 2 hands. I bet 1 dollar in all negative counts, 25 in positive counts, and when I reach +4 I bet 2 hands of 25.

So even spreading 1-50, the EV isn't anything earth-shattering, so what camo could I use to hide a 1-50 spread? Actually, I know of something. I could tip. If I tipped they would not care what I do since they are making money. And there is no pit watching, so if the dealer is happy, there is noone to stop me. But how much can I afford to tip at this game? I was thinking about tipping (50 cents) only when I get a BJ, but how much of my EV would I be giving up?
 

ihate17

Well-Known Member
No kind of casino, it is a bar

biggamejames said:
What kind of casino allows the dealers to read books while attending a table?

Why would you even begin to debate the legality of your play with a dealer?

Arent you supposed to talk to a pit boss not some dodo head dealer reading a book?

why would you even walk into a casino where the dealer reads a book at the table????:confused:
You have a bar with a table or two, definately not the Belaggio.

ihate17
 

ScottH

Well-Known Member
NDN21 said:
Just how obvious were you guys?
I was as obvious as humanly possible. Speading 1-50, pretty much no ramping of bets. It doesn't take an AP to know something is going on, especially when I seem to keep getting 20's and BJ's when the green come down. Every once in a while I would get comments on my "weird betting style". But I didn't care. These local games are not where me and supercool are going to make our money... although making a little bit would be nice for our "business trip" in LV this summer...
 
ScottH said:
I don't really want to play any camo at these games. They aren't very good. They are 4d, das, s17, 70-75% pen. The big thing is, the limits are low, 1-25. You can't really make much unless you spread huge. So that's what I do, I spread from 1-2x25. They only allow you to go to 2 hands. I bet 1 dollar in all negative counts, 25 in positive counts, and when I reach +4 I bet 2 hands of 25.

So even spreading 1-50, the EV isn't anything earth-shattering, so what camo could I use to hide a 1-50 spread? Actually, I know of something. I could tip. If I tipped they would not care what I do since they are making money. And there is no pit watching, so if the dealer is happy, there is noone to stop me. But how much can I afford to tip at this game? I was thinking about tipping (50 cents) only when I get a BJ, but how much of my EV would I be giving up?
Too much.

Look it's summer and school's out, right? How about you and your partner get in the car with your bankrolls, laptops and a Motel 6 catalog and hit the road? You guys have the dedication and the knowledge, what are you jerking yourselves around with a $25 max game for? You have some excellent games just a few hours to the East, and I suggest you get out there and see what real blackjack in real casinos is like.
 

ScottH

Well-Known Member
nc-tom said:
Hey Scott why bother with all the leagel bs. i thought you and SCM were going to move to LV and make big money playing bj. Why take a chance at mucking up your future play?
I was just going to do it for fun. I pretty much knew nothing was going to come of it since it would not really benefit me in any way, like Sonny mentioned. It would just be a great waste of time.

Me and supercool are going to only do team tactics now, so it won't look like we are counting. Only thing is we will still be spreading, just not with the count, so they will probably still think we are counting. They will probably correctly ban us, but for the wrong reason. We'll just burn out all the games we have locally and move on. No big deal.
 
Top