yes to all that with a few variations on the theme that are reflected by theological and philosophical questions that mankind and individuals are wrestling with.
:whip:
and this is fine with me as well as long as we don't confuse it with the question of dealing with uncertainty.
this goes for advantage play. advantage play as percieved by this most fun and esteemed community of forums on blackjackinfo.com et. al is not a matter of Truth. advantage play as such is a body of knowledge, in essence a theory only analogous of truth in the sense of logical conclusions drawn from assumptions for which there is no way possible to prove that those assumptions are truth.
if you still want to play blackjack according to the premise "Yes, it is our job to play the best game of Blackjack that we can." and if you want to "know a certain course of action is the right thing to do, do it. Take the shortcut and do what is right. Quit the rationalizing. Quit the double agenda. Quit being double minded. Choose the straight and narrow."
then consider the theory of blackjack and consider the implications about theories, science and mathematics compliments of Goedel:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gödel's_incompleteness_theorems
hence:
too me (according to my current state of ponderance) in essence the question of blackjack advantage play boils down to uncertainty and therefore for the prudent minded risk, risk that is above and beyond theoretical ROR. this is true for me for two reasons:
1. i'm not capable to understand the complete logic and maths of blackjack theory.
2. even if i were capable, i'd still (in my mathematical & scientific enthusiasim) have to realize that Truth it is not. close maybe, but no cigar.
so in the end i'm stuck with my trembling fearful self and the uncertainty/risk of the theory of blackjack when i take a seat at a blackjack table.
in short just like all of the other challenges of life i'm not about to reliquish my rationality over the theory of genius's when faced with uncertainty and risk.
i've seen in my escapades in casino's obviously groups of young fellows putting all of their faith in blackjack theory. the dejected looks as they leave the tables with pockets turned inside out stands testimate of a likely large and unknown cemetary of failed AP's. unsung hero's that don't post on blackjackinfo.com.
lol, no brag just fact, i'm still here posting after nearly three years. not rich by any means from my blackjack endeavors but not broke either.:cat: